Manara Erotic Tarot
Christopher delaMaison, CPTR
By day, Christopher delaMaison is a
mild-mannered computer instructor at a private college in Wilsonville,
Oregon. By night, he may be found doing tarot readings or drumming for
belly dancers at the local SCA events. This summer, Christopher will be
teaching beginning tarot classes at the August 1st Seadog Nights/Gypsy
Carnival, in Marcola, Oregon. When not reading tarot or drumming,
Christopher can be found hanging out with his Sci-Fi friends on “Klingon
Karaoke Night” at Bodacious Classics in Portland.
Check out this link.
His web site:
www.delamaison.com features a
number of items which you simply have to see for yourself.
Originally, I picked this deck up to compare it to
the Casanova deck,
also from Lo Scarabeo, that I had purchased much earlier. After looking
through this deck, I find that it isn’t a comparable deck to the Casanova
at all, but a wholly different deck, with it’s own feel and purpose.
The Manara deck is published by Lo Scarabeo in Italy, and is imported by
Llewellyn Worldwide. The artwork used in the deck is from an Italian
artist and writer Milo Manara. Manara specializes in erotic comic books
and paperbacks, which feature a number of female characters that are
placed in various situations spanning the full range of sexual situations.
Several of the pictures used in this deck are his more well-known works,
such as the Ace of Air, which is the cover girl on his paperback El
My first Lo Scarabeo deck was the Universal deck, which I use as my main
“working” deck. I have always been very pleased with Lo Scarabeo decks, as
they all seem to come with a small booklet, giving the new reader a few
quick hints, as well as some background into the deck, as well as general
tarot reading tips.
Like the Casanova deck, the Manara deck has Justice as the Eighth and
Strength as the Eleventh Major Arcanas. As my original tarot training was
in the Masonic lodge, I am use to seeing these cards in their transposed
positions, as presented in the Rider-Waite-Smith deck. For most seasoned
readers, this transposition is usually not a problem.
Another interesting difference with the Manara deck is his substitution of
the alchemical symbols of Fire for Wands, Water for Cups, Air for Swords,
and Earth for Pentacles. Manara uses this vehicle to keep the deck aligned
with these four elements, but is still able to divest himself of the
standard symbols for these tarot suits. This allows the artist the freedom
to use artwork for a particular card that may not have the standard tarot
The problem with jettisoning the standard tarot symbols is that these
symbols form the currency with which we exchange our impressions and
insights of our readings with our clients. The standard tarot symbols are
items deeply imbedded within our culture and psyche. They cannot be simply
done away with for artistic license.
Now, while I am no expert on erotic art, I have to say that some of the
cards are intriguing, some are a bit disturbing, and some simply fall
flat. A good example can be seen by comparing the four Ace cards of the
deck. The Ace of Earth shows a young woman with light brown hair and a
dark green wreath. Although there is no sign of anything that would
suggest a pentacle, this picture comes across as being very grounding and
The Ace of Air shows a woman holding a long stem pipe. I could see the
Air-Smoke connection here, but then again an argument could be made for a
Smoke-Fire connection as well. The Ace of Water shows a woman in a red
British military coat, with a ship in the background. Again, the red coat
would lead me to think of a fire connection here, rather than a water
connection. The Ace of Fire shows a woman eating what looks like a
chocolate heart. This brings to mind a heart-cups connection, rather than
a fire connection.
Looking at the
Kings of this deck does not seem to help clarify matters. The King of
Fire is an Indian shaman from the southwest. He is holding a flint
dagger, dressed in yellow and orange robes. This does seem to convey
an image of fire. Likewise, the King of Water shows a young man
dressed in blue jeans and a dark blue shirt. This guy does look like a
water sign, and could very well pass as the King of Water. The King of
Air is another Indian shaman, holding a staff. This is a more confused
picture. His hair (what little there is of it) is blowing in the wind,
but aside from that, there is nothing in this scene to convey the idea
of Air, quickness of thought, or anything that could be related to the
suit of Swords in a conventional deck. The King of Earth shows what
looks like an elderly schoolmaster, reaching through a thicket with a
stick, trying to lift up a schoolgirl’s skirt. Somehow, this doesn’t
seem to bring to mind the same influence the King of Pentacles does
for me in a regular Rider-Waite-Smith deck.
Putting aside the
incongruities of Manara vs. Rider-Waite symbolism, the artwork brings
out other responses that are both intriguing and disturbing. The
Magician shows a woman assembling a robot lizard-man, with a large,
flexible penis. This robot has an alligator-like head and large claws.
It has very little appeal, except for the phallus she is working on.
Like the Magician in other decks, she is working very studiously on
her project, but it seems much less noble than the traditional scene
of pulling down power from the universe to charge the symbols of the
tarot suit. There is a much more “pedestrian” feel to this scene. The
nobility of the “magic worker” is not there.
Another Major Arcana that seems to be a bit disturbing is the Justice
card. This card shows a woman peeking out from behind a carved wood
screen. She isn’t carrying a set of scales or a sword, she is just peeking
out from behind a screen. To me, this isn’t the Lady of Justice. This
character seems to be more timid and frightened than ready to weigh the
truth of matters brought before her, and deal out justice. Justice, as a
concept or universal equalization, must be able to stand out in the light,
not peek around corners.
One court card that does stand out as being representative of its suit is
the Knave of Air. This card shows a worker dancing to the tune he is
hearing through his headphones. Holding a wrench and dressed in greasy,
dirty overalls, he is light on his feet, dancing around what looks like a
jet of escaping steam; perhaps the problem he is suppose to be working on.
This card seems to be very light and airy, matching the lady in the Ace of
Many of the cards have a more playful character. They show young women
teasing men, and being very self-confident and assertive. This adds to the
attractiveness of the deck in general. For myself, I would be less
inclined to use this deck in any serious divination for my clients. I
would, however, be tempted to bring this deck out at a party, where the
participants were consenting, mature adults exploring their sexual desires
Published by Lo
Scarabeo, Torino, Italy. Available in the U.S. from Llewellyn Worldwide,
Ltd. ISBN 0-73870-022-3.